[All] Padangu putimas azoto dujomis

Moderators: zygasbmw, stashas

Forum rules
Kiekviena tema šioje skiltyje turi prasidėti automobilio kodu laužtiniuos skliaustuose (pvz.: [E30])
Post Reply
User avatar
tankas
Posts: 1041
Joined: 30 Jan 2007 15:33
BMW: KTM 640SM + Kawasaki ZX9R
Location: Dublin

[All] Padangu putimas azoto dujomis

Post by tankas » 09 Jun 2008 20:36

Idesiu istrauka is TyreBilble kur apraso jog tai jokios praktiskos naudos neduoda. Raso kad geriau pripusti padangas kuo "sausesniu oru".




Nitrogen inflation

nitrogenNitrogen inflation (nitrogen filled tyres) is one of those topics that gets discussed in car circles a lot. Some people swear by it, whilst others consider it to be an expensive rip off. So what's the big idea? Well there are two common theories on this.

Theory 1: nitrogen molecules are larger than oxygen molecules so they won't permeate through the rubber of the tyre like oxygen will, and thus you'll never lose pressure over time due to leakage. The fact is any gas will leak out of a tyre if its at a higher pressure than the ambient pressure outside. The only way to stop it is a non-gas-permeable membrane lining the inside of the tyre.
The science bit: Water is about half the size of either nitrogen or oxygen, so it might diffuse out of the tyre faster, but it would have to be much, much faster to make a difference. Tyres can leak 1-2 psi a month at the extreme end of the scale although it's not clear how much of that is by permeation through the rubber, and how much is through microscopic leaks of various sorts. For a racing tyre to lose significant water during its racing lifetime (maybe an hour or so for Formula 1), the permeation rate would have to be hundreds of times faster than oxygen or nitrogen, so that pretty much cancels out the idea that it's the molecule size that makes the difference.

Theory 2: Nitrogen means less water vapour. This is more to do with the thermal properties than anything else. Nitrogen is an inert gas; it doesn't combust or oxidise. The process used to compress nitrogen eliminates water vapor and that's the key to this particular theory. When a tyre heats up under normal use, any water vapour inside it also heats up which causes an increase in tyre pressure. By removing water vapor with a pure nitrogen fill, you're basically going to allow the tyre to stay at a more constant pressure irrespective of temperature over the life of the tyre. In other words, your tyre pressures won't change as you drive.
The science bit: The van der Waals gas equation provides a good estimate for comparing the expansions of oxygen and nitrogen to water. If you compare moist air (20°C, 80% RH) to nitrogen, you'll find that going up as far as 80°C results in the moist air increasing in pressure by about 0.01 psi less per litre volume than nitrogen. Moist air will increase in pressure by 7.253psi whereas nitrogen will increase in pressure by 7.263psi. Even humid air has only a small amount of water in it (about 2 mole % which means about 2% by volume), so that all puts a bit of a blunt tip on the theory that it's the differences in thermal expansion rates that give nitrogen an advantage. In fact it would seem to suggest that damp air is marginally better than nitrogen. Go figure.

So which option is right - smaller molecules, or less water vapour? It would seem neither. A reader of this site had a good thought on the whole nitrogen inflation thing. He wrote: Some racer who did not know the details of chemistry and physics thought that nitrogen would be better because (insert plausible but incorrect science here) and he started using nitrogen. He won some races and word got out that he was using nitrogen in his tires. Well, it is not expensive to use nitrogen in place of air, so pretty soon everyone was doing it. Hey, until I hear a reason that makes good scientific sense, this explanation seems just as good.

Nitrogen inflation is nothing new - the aerospace world has been doing it for years in aircraft tyres. Racing teams will also often use nitrogen inflation, but largely out of conveience rather than due to any specific performance benefit, which would tend to fit with the armchair science outlined above. Nitrogen is supplied in pressurised tanks, so no other equipment is needed to inflate the tyres - no compressors or generators or anything.

So does it make a difference to drivers in the real world? Well consider this; The air you breathe is already made up of 78% nitrogen. The composition is completed by 21% oxygen and tiny percentages of argon, carbon dioxide, neon, methane, helium, krypton, hydrogen and xenon. The kit that is used to generate nitrogen for road tyres typically only gets to about 95% purity. To get close to that in your tyres, you'd need to inflate and deflate them several times to purge any remaining oxygen and even then you're only likely to get about 90% pure nitrogen. So under ideal conditions, you're increasing the nitrogen content of the gas in the tyre from 78% to 90%. Given that nitrogen inflation from the average tyre workshop is a one-shot deal (no purging involved) you're more likely to be driving around with 80% pure nitrogen than 90%. That's a 2% difference from bog standard air. On top of that, nitrogen inflation doesn't make your tyres any less prone to damage from road debris and punctures and such. It doesn't make them any stronger, and if you need to top them up and use a regular garage air-line to do it, you've diluted whatever purity of nitrogen was in the tyres right there. For $30 a tyre for nitrogen inflation, do you think that's worth it? For all the alleged benefits of a nitrogen fill, you'd be far better off finding a tyre change place that has a vapour-elimination system in their air compressor. If they can pump up your tyres with dry air, you'll get about the same benefits as you would with a nitrogen inflation but for free.
"Obviously, the faster you travel, the sooner you get to where you’re going. So you can see more and do more and learn more. Speed makes you cleverer." - Jeremy Clarkson

megejas
Posts: 124
Joined: 30 Jan 2006 10:25
BMW: e38 735,Subaru Impreza
Location: Kaunas

Re: [All] Padangu putimas azoto dujomis

Post by megejas » 11 Jun 2008 09:27

Melgoj pildo atrodo. O nauda kiek isivaizduoju kad nuo temperaturos skirtumo turis nesikeicia.

User avatar
tankas
Posts: 1041
Joined: 30 Jan 2007 15:33
BMW: KTM 640SM + Kawasaki ZX9R
Location: Dublin

Re: [All] Padangu putimas azoto dujomis

Post by tankas » 11 Jun 2008 13:11

megejas wrote:Melgoj pildo atrodo. O nauda kiek isivaizduoju kad nuo temperaturos skirtumo turis nesikeicia.
Taigi paskaityk kas angliskai parasryta. Neverta moketi uz tokia paslauga.
"Obviously, the faster you travel, the sooner you get to where you’re going. So you can see more and do more and learn more. Speed makes you cleverer." - Jeremy Clarkson

m20b25

Re: [All] Padangu putimas azoto dujomis

Post by m20b25 » 11 Jun 2008 15:28

O degalinese esantis oras yra per slapias ? :kar Kaip pasireiskia tas sausas oras ???

Syncro

User avatar
tankas
Posts: 1041
Joined: 30 Jan 2007 15:33
BMW: KTM 640SM + Kawasaki ZX9R
Location: Dublin

Re: [All] Padangu putimas azoto dujomis

Post by tankas » 11 Jun 2008 15:34

m20b25 wrote:O degalinese esantis oras yra per slapias ? :kar Kaip pasireiskia tas sausas oras ???

Syncro
Yra toks parametras "santykinis oro dregnumas". Per zinias kur pasakoja :) Juk kabutese parasiau kuo "sausesniu oru". Normaliose padangu montavimo servisuose (tikriausiai dar ne Lietuvoje) kompresoriai kuriais pucia padangas turi dregmes salinimo filtrus, taigi pucia "sausu oru". Maziau dregmes, maziau kyla slegis sylant padangoms.
"Obviously, the faster you travel, the sooner you get to where you’re going. So you can see more and do more and learn more. Speed makes you cleverer." - Jeremy Clarkson

User avatar
Trintukazzz
Posts: 131
Joined: 21 Jun 2006 23:44
BMW: ex E30 320i Touring
Location: Kaunas
Contact:

Re: [All] Padangu putimas azoto dujomis

Post by Trintukazzz » 22 Jun 2008 23:35

wisuose kompresuoriuose keik zinau yra nuorinimas.. kaip ir radijatoriuose :D jei bus dregmes,tai nesuks nei orinis,nei ora normaliai pus..
BMW E30 2.0 Touring

User avatar
Simookas
Posts: 346
Joined: 18 Jun 2008 21:33
BMW: E39 diesel
Location: Vilnius
Contact:

Re: [All] Padangu putimas azoto dujomis

Post by Simookas » 24 Jun 2008 13:41

na nzn pvz pas mane servise dazymo kameroj tai tikrai oras sausas nes negali but dazant jokio kondensato bet kad visai vienodai tom padangom,manau neverta ten kisti pinigu galima paieskot pazistamu servise

User avatar
b@b@tuk@s
Posts: 915
Joined: 17 Jul 2006 20:54
BMW: e36 316i
Location: Kaunas

Re: [All] Padangu putimas azoto dujomis

Post by b@b@tuk@s » 25 Jun 2008 18:26

Mes pildom azotu... kiek galiu paprastai paaiskinti tai ten ora maiso su azotu kazkaip ir tiesiog kai vaziuoji padangoje nesikeicia temperatura ir nekinta slygis t.y (kai prisiputi ten 2.2 tarkim pavazineji ilgiau ir poto buna 2.6~ 3.0~ tai priputus to azoto vadinamojo tai nesikeicia temperatura ir slegis... siaip gal ir neblogas dalykas... :D

romkasponka
Posts: 1350
Joined: 26 Feb 2006 20:23
BMW: E30 318is, E36 318is
Location: VNO
Contact:

Re: [All] Padangu putimas azoto dujomis

Post by romkasponka » 25 Jun 2008 19:22

megejas wrote:Melgoj pildo atrodo. O nauda kiek isivaizduoju kad nuo temperaturos skirtumo turis nesikeicia.
pasiskaityk fizikos vadoveli kaip keichiasi slegis nuo temperaturos ir suprasi, kad skirtumas gausis ant tiek mazas, kad jo praktishkai nepajausi niekaip (skirtumas tarp oro ir gryno azoto). Vienintele nauda yra ta, kad jei super duper vakumu sugebesi ishsiurbti visa ora ish rato, o vietoje jo prileisti azoto tai nauda bus ta, kad sumazinsi oksidacijos proceso itaka prie aukshtu temperaturu, t.y. lenktynese. F1 komandos naudoja slaptus ivairiu duju mishinius ir sako, kad tai duoda 10-15% ilgesne rida slikams ir dar kazkokios mistines teorijos apie geresni shilumos atidavima i ratlanki esu skaites, bet taip pat buvo daug prieshtaringu nuomoniu. Aviacijoje azotas naudojamas ir del kitos priezasties, jis tiesiog neskatina degimo.
E30 318is
E36 318is
E83 3,0d
romkasponka
http://www.greitiems.lt
http://romkasponka.autogidas.lt/

romkasponka
Posts: 1350
Joined: 26 Feb 2006 20:23
BMW: E30 318is, E36 318is
Location: VNO
Contact:

Re: [All] Padangu putimas azoto dujomis

Post by romkasponka » 25 Jun 2008 19:25

b@b@tuk@s wrote:Mes pildom azotu... kiek galiu paprastai paaiskinti tai ten ora maiso su azotu kazkaip ir tiesiog kai vaziuoji padangoje nesikeicia temperatura ir nekinta slygis t.y (kai prisiputi ten 2.2 tarkim pavazineji ilgiau ir poto buna 2.6~ 3.0~ tai priputus to azoto vadinamojo tai nesikeicia temperatura ir slegis... siaip gal ir neblogas dalykas... :D
matyt atradot nauja fizikos desni, pretenduojat i valstybes premija? :D
E30 318is
E36 318is
E83 3,0d
romkasponka
http://www.greitiems.lt
http://romkasponka.autogidas.lt/

User avatar
tankas
Posts: 1041
Joined: 30 Jan 2007 15:33
BMW: KTM 640SM + Kawasaki ZX9R
Location: Dublin

Re: [All] Padangu putimas azoto dujomis

Post by tankas » 28 Jun 2008 14:50

romkasponka wrote:matyt atradot nauja fizikos desni...
Manau tiesiog visi tingi paskaityti pirma post'a.
"Obviously, the faster you travel, the sooner you get to where you’re going. So you can see more and do more and learn more. Speed makes you cleverer." - Jeremy Clarkson

User avatar
b@b@tuk@s
Posts: 915
Joined: 17 Jul 2006 20:54
BMW: e36 316i
Location: Kaunas

Re: [All] Padangu putimas azoto dujomis

Post by b@b@tuk@s » 29 Jun 2008 20:52

tankas wrote:
romkasponka wrote:matyt atradot nauja fizikos desni...
Manau tiesiog visi tingi paskaityti pirma post'a.
gal nesupranta eng... :D sorry uz ot

User avatar
Kasperskis
Posts: 94
Joined: 19 Jun 2008 08:05
BMW: E36 320 M52 triuksmadarys
Location: Vilniius

Re: [All] Padangu putimas azoto dujomis

Post by Kasperskis » 30 Jun 2008 11:55

Melgoi azoto putimas nemokamai jau... pats dirbu :) beto netik kad nesikeicia slegis, bet jei pvz kazkur leidzia pro nedidele skylute oras, netaip greit iseina nes tankis ne toks :) ir seip jauciasi man skirtumas vazevime ipuciu 2.6 ir man atrodo kad oro maziau :D

romkasponka
Posts: 1350
Joined: 26 Feb 2006 20:23
BMW: E30 318is, E36 318is
Location: VNO
Contact:

Re: [All] Padangu putimas azoto dujomis

Post by romkasponka » 30 Jun 2008 14:47

Kasperskis wrote:Melgoi azoto putimas nemokamai jau... pats dirbu :) beto netik kad nesikeicia slegis, bet jei pvz kazkur leidzia pro nedidele skylute oras, netaip greit iseina nes tankis ne toks :) ir seip jauciasi man skirtumas vazevime ipuciu 2.6 ir man atrodo kad oro maziau :D
dar vienas busimas premijos lauretas..
E30 318is
E36 318is
E83 3,0d
romkasponka
http://www.greitiems.lt
http://romkasponka.autogidas.lt/

User avatar
unguriux
BMW Fan narys
Posts: 1446
Joined: 08 Jun 2007 12:34
BMW: E34 525i Touring
Location: Klaipėda
Contact:

Re: [All] Padangu putimas azoto dujomis

Post by unguriux » 30 Jun 2008 14:48

Kasperskis wrote:Melgoi azoto putimas nemokamai jau... pats dirbu :) beto netik kad nesikeicia slegis, bet jei pvz kazkur leidzia pro nedidele skylute oras, netaip greit iseina nes tankis ne toks :) ir seip jauciasi man skirtumas vazevime ipuciu 2.6 ir man atrodo kad oro maziau :D

:appl :appl :appl :D :-D :-D :i
do u read english? :D
Beveik visi automobilių remonto darbai 863170882 Nerka
Starterių ir generatorių remontas 867044733 Andriuxa

romkasponka
Posts: 1350
Joined: 26 Feb 2006 20:23
BMW: E30 318is, E36 318is
Location: VNO
Contact:

Re: [All] Padangu putimas azoto dujomis

Post by romkasponka » 30 Jun 2008 14:53

Man tai biski keista, zmones puchia azotu ir dar tokias nesamones rasho, savo nekompetencija demonstruoja ir firmos varda gadina... :appl
E30 318is
E36 318is
E83 3,0d
romkasponka
http://www.greitiems.lt
http://romkasponka.autogidas.lt/

sPunky

Re: [All] Padangu putimas azoto dujomis

Post by sPunky » 03 Jul 2008 23:04

kas nerisa angliskai, manau esminis sakinys: kad ore kuris mus supa ir taip jau yra 78% azoto sudedamoji dalis... :D

User avatar
tankas
Posts: 1041
Joined: 30 Jan 2007 15:33
BMW: KTM 640SM + Kawasaki ZX9R
Location: Dublin

Re: [All] Padangu putimas azoto dujomis

Post by tankas » 04 Jul 2008 12:04

sPunky wrote:kas nerisa angliskai, manau esminis sakinys: kad ore kuris mus supa ir taip jau yra 78% azoto sudedamoji dalis... :D
Truputi patikslinsiu (dlia asoba tupych :D) - ore kuriuo mes kvepuojame ir puciamos padangos, ir taip jau yra 78% azoto duju...


Tai nuvaziaves prisipusti ale su azoto dujomis vietoj 78%, gausi 80% azoto duju padangose. Kas nesudaro visiskai jokio skirtumo kad ir kaip bevzaziuotum.
"Obviously, the faster you travel, the sooner you get to where you’re going. So you can see more and do more and learn more. Speed makes you cleverer." - Jeremy Clarkson

Post Reply